That of Israel longest war it has thus far did not destroy its foremost enemy, Hamas, which, regardless of struggling devastating losses, is presenting the Gaza ceasefire settlement as a victory for itself – and a failure for Israel.
Immediately after a cease-fire took impact on Sunday, masked gunmen emerged in automobiles roaming the devastated streets of Gaza to have a good time. Members of an elite unit wore full uniform in Al Saraya Square in Gaza City through the hostage switch. It was a technique to remind Hamas that its armed wing was nonetheless right here 15 months after Israel determined to destroy them.
One of Hamas’ foremost goals in taking round 250 hostages through the brazen assault on Israel on 7 October 2023 was to safe the discharge of Palestinian prisoners held in Israeli prisons. As Israel struck Gaza in response, Hamas vowed to not return the hostages till Israel withdrew its forces from the enclave, lastly ended the warfare and allowed reconstruction.
After greater than a yr of clashes, Hamas and Israel have reached a gradual settlement in latest days which offers for the discharge of the hostages in alternate for Palestinian prisoners, in addition to a 42-day ceasefire and the entry of help. The settlement additionally opens the door to additional negotiations that would lead to an entire Israeli withdrawal from Gaza and a everlasting ceasefire.
“(The settlement) fulfills all these situations… the resistance has achieved what the Palestinian folks need,” Osama Hamdan, a senior political member of Hamas, advised Al Jazeera after an settlement was reached.
Khalil Al Hayya, Hamas’s high negotiator, mentioned in a speech Wednesday that Israel had failed to attain its warfare objectives and praised Hamas’s armed wing, the Al Qassam Brigades, whose spokesman Abu Obaida praised the warfare in Gaza as an “inspiration” for generations to return. Israel’s foremost purpose of the battle was to remove Hamas.
Some ministers, parliamentarians and even a small minority of hostage households see acceptance of the deal as an Israeli defeat. Far-right minister Itamar Ben Gvir and his get together resigned from the federal government and the Knesset (parliament), calling the truce a “give up.” A right-wing colleague, Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich, known as it “catastrophic,” and a gaggle of Army reservists labeled it “The Surrender Deal.”
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, heart, convenes his safety cupboard to vote on the ceasefire settlement on January 17, 2025. – Koby Gideon/GPO/AP
“When you see… the dancing in Gaza, the celebrations within the villages of Judea and Samaria – you perceive which facet has surrendered to this settlement,” Ben Gvir mentioned in a press release Thursday. Judea and Samaria is what Israel calls the West Bank.
But most in Israel welcome the deal, together with the vast majority of the hostages’ households, Israeli President Isaac Herzog and the political opposition. Netanyahu’s workplace mentioned after the safety cupboard authorised the deal that the prime minister continues to “help reaching the goals of the warfare.”
A neon signal referencing the Israeli hostages held in Gaza atop the Charles Bronfman auditorium in HaBima Square in Tel Aviv on December 9, 2023. – Ahmad Gharabli/AFP/Getty Images
A supply conversant in the matter advised CNN that Netanyahu advised ministers that the United States had offered ensures “that if Hamas sabotages a sure part of the settlement, Israel will be capable of resume combating.”
“The survival of Hamas is a defeat for Israel”
Israel’s response to Hamas for the October 7 assault was intense. It leveled Gaza underneath probably the most violent bombing marketing campaign within the enclave’s historical past, killing tens of hundreds of Palestinians and displacing a whole lot of hundreds extra, a lot of whom had been pressured to dwell in tents with little meals and insufficient medical care.
Israel additionally inflicted heavy casualties on Hamas, killing its high leaders, together with the mastermind of the October 7 assault, Yahya Sinwar, and mentioned it had killed hundreds of the group’s fighters. He was relentless in rooting out re-emerging militants in beforehand cleared neighborhoods, all whereas combating, and finally defeating, Lebanese Hezbollah within the north, which had opened a brand new entrance in opposition to Israel in help of Gaza.
Hamas, which as soon as had army and political management of Gaza, has been decreased to a fraction of what it as soon as was after Israel’s 15-month marketing campaign, and with the numerous weakening of its regional allies Hezbollah and Iran, the group is turned regionally remoted.
Displaced Palestinians return to the Jabalia refugee camp within the war-torn northern Gaza Strip on January 19, 2025, shortly earlier than the implementation of the ceasefire settlement. -Omar Al-Qattaa/AFP/Getty Images
Yet the motion has continued to current itself to Palestinians as probably the most formidable armed resistance group in opposition to Israel, replenishing its ranks by recruiting nearly as many new militants because it has misplaced.
“Every time Israel completes its army operations and withdraws, Hamas militants regroup and reemerge as a result of there’s nothing else to fill the void,” US Secretary of State Antony Blinken mentioned not too long ago in a speech at Atlantic Council.
“In reality, we consider that Hamas has recruited as many new militants because it has misplaced. This is the recipe for lasting riot and perpetual warfare.”
Tahani Mustafa, a senior analyst on the International Crisis Group (ICG), argues that the struggling inflicted on Palestinians in Gaza by the Israeli warfare creates fertile floor for recruitment.
“You can see a rise in recruitment exactly as a result of when there’s occupation and violence you could find relevance,” he advised CNN. “How are you able to count on whole swaths of the Gaza inhabitants who’ve misplaced the whole lot to easily give in? It’s a warfare for survival. Groups like Hamas present (Palestinians) the means to take action.”
In his feedback to the Atlantic Council, Blinken mentioned the United States has emphasised to the Israeli authorities “that Hamas can’t be defeated with a army marketing campaign alone, that and not using a clear different, a post-conflict plan and a reputable political rise of the Palestinians, Hamas or one thing equally repugnant and harmful will develop once more.”
Hamas pledges to rebuild
The governance of post-war Gaza stays unresolved, maybe resulting from skepticism about whether or not the ceasefire settlement will progress past the preliminary part. Israel’s final warfare purpose is the whole destruction of Hamas. But Hamas seems unconcerned, suggesting that its cadres will play a task in rebuilding the devastated enclave. “The whole inhabitants, and the resistance as a part of it, will start to rebuild what the occupation has destroyed,” Hamdan advised Al Jazeera.
Hamdan argued that whatever the end result, the following day in Gaza will stay much like the day earlier than.
“The subsequent day, it is like right this moment, it is just like the day earlier than… will probably be a Palestinian day,” Hamdan mentioned.
Members of the International Committee of the Red Cross communicate with fighters from the Ezzedine al-Qassam Brigades, the armed wing of Hamas, in Saraya Square in western Gaza City on January 19, 2025. – Omar Al-Qattaa/AFP by way of Getty Images
While Hamas can declare victory, it has did not power Israel to raise the crippling siege on Gaza and has presided over Israeli assaults which have killed tens of hundreds of Palestinian civilians and made Gaza unlivable. The October 7 assault, and the warfare it sparked, had a ripple impact, considerably altering the regional steadiness of energy and basically reshaping the area.
Hamas doesn’t see its personal survival as an goal on this warfare, however for Israel the group’s very survival might be thought-about a “defeat,” mentioned the ICG’s Mustafa.
For extra CNN information and newsletters, create an account at CNN.com
